GuidesGuides

How Irish interview boards score: the marking sheets for Civil Service, HSE, council and Garda interviews

Every Irish public sector board scores against a sheet, and most of those sheets are public if you know where to look. This guide sets out the scales side by side, what the band words mean, how ties are broken, and the habits boards are trained to penalise.

StarMethod.ie · Published 13 October 2026 · 14 min read

A board member in a dark jacket holding a clipboard and pen
Photo: Mikhail Nilov, Pexels

What every sheet has in common

An Irish public sector interview is scored one competency at a time, on a numbered scale, against written indicators, with a minimum you must reach in every competency to be placed on the panel. Total marks then set your place on the panel. That structure is the same whether the sheet says 1 to 50, 1 to 100, 1 to 5 or 200 marks, and it has two consequences for how you prepare. A brilliant answer in one area cannot carry a weak one, and the board is not scoring the interview as a whole but hunting for evidence under each heading in turn.

The sheets themselves are rarely published in full. publicjobs says in its 2024 Annual Report that it issues an interview guide template, a scoring guide and a candidate feedback template to client departments, but none of these are on its website. The HSE went to the Information Commissioner in 2025 to keep its Grade VII interview guidelines confidential, and won on the point that releasing the exact indicators boards probe would force a redesign. What follows is assembled from the documents that are public: the booklets that state scales and pass marks, the HSE’s own candidate and board-member guides, council booklets, and the board-training material that the Northern Ireland Civil Service publishes and that Irish boards follow in substance.

Civil Service, Capability Framework: 1 to 50 per sub-dimension

The one Capability Framework mark scheme published in full is in the Department of Social Protection’s AO ICT booklet of June 2026, run under the CPSA Code. Each sub-dimension is scored from 1 to 50, drawing on the Capability Framework indicators for the grade. The AO interview covers eight sub-dimensions, so eight scores, maximum 400. Open publicjobs competitions for CO, EO, HEO and AP use the same framework; the number of sub-dimensions assessed varies by grade and is stated in the booklet.

BandMarksBooklet definition
Fail1 to 17Insufficient evidence of capability, limited experience or transferable skills, little knowledge and understanding of the area, at the level required for the role.
Potential18 to 21Some or limited direct experience, but demonstrates capability to learn and holds transferable skills. Shows an understanding of the appropriate actions to take and can describe the correct approach, at the level required.
Pass (Good)22 to 34Good capability and experience, at the level required for the role.
Pass (Very Good to Excellent)35 to 50Very good to excellent capability and experience, at the level required for the role.

The rule that matters: a Potential score is tolerated in one sub-dimension only. “If a candidate fails any sub dimension or receives two potential scores, they will be deemed to be unsuccessful.” Potential is the framework’s formal way of letting a candidate with transferable skills but no direct experience through in one area, and publicjobs tells candidates to prepare for exactly that: where you have limited direct experience, reflect on transferable skills and how you would go about demonstrating capability if placed in the role.

Note the phrase that appears in every band: “at the level required for the role”. The indicators differ by grade, and an example that would be Very Good for a Clerical Officer can sit at Potential for an Executive Officer because it shows no judgement above the CO level. Candidates on r/IrishCivilService put it as: to place highly you have to be already operating as the grade you applied for. Coaching testimonials quote real feedback as “1 x 90 and 4 x 80s”, so some boards report per-dimension scores out of 100 rather than 50; the bands scale the same way.

Civil Service, Competency Model: a percentage per competency

Competitions still run on the older Civil Service Competency Model, which includes many department-run competitions and Revenue, score each competency on its own scale and set a percentage minimum. Revenue’s Customs Officer booklet for 2025 states it: candidates “must meet a minimum standard of 55% in each scoring area to be considered for inclusion on the panel”, with the panel ranked by total score. Your invitation email tells you which model applies, and candidates in 2026 are blunt about the risk of preparing for the wrong one, because the headings and the questions differ. The Capability Framework guide sets out both.

HSE: 1 to 100, or 1 to 5, minimum in every area

HSE campaign documents publish the scoring guide in full and it comes in two sizes. Many 2026 campaign documents, including the Grade VII and senior clinical campaigns, use 1 to 100 per skill area with a minimum of 40 in each. Others use 1 to 5 with a minimum of 2. Your Additional Campaign Information document says which. The band words are what the board writes next to your score.

1 to 1001 to 5Applicant document wordingBoard guide wording
1 to 391 to 1.99Little evidence of this key skill area presentedNot acceptable: patchy, significant weak areas, little or no evidence
40 to 692 to 2.99Adequate or satisfactory evidenceAcceptable: achieves a sufficiently high standard to work at the target job level
70 to 893 to 3.99Good evidenceGood: an area of distinctive strength
90 to 1004 to 5Strong evidence (1 to 5 scale: Excellent 4 to 4.99, Outstanding 5)Exceptional: difficult to see how it could be improved upon, a role model

The HSE’s guide for board members adds how the number is reached. Each member rates independently straight after the interview, then the board agrees a consensus score, and members are told to use the full breadth of the scale. Evidence from anywhere in the interview can count toward any area, so a point you make under Team Working can be credited under Communication. Failing one area fails the interview. The candidate document warns that the wording on your sheet may vary: a score of 40 to 69 may be described as sufficient, adequate, satisfactory or reasonable.

The comment is written to a template: name, an anchor word from the band, the skill area, and a reference to the example. The guide’s own illustration runs “John displayed adequate evidence of his ability to plan and organise in his example where he...”, and weaknesses are phrased positively as “would benefit from better demonstrating his ability to...”. Every candidate receives the sheet with scores and comments alongside the result letter. Interviews are mostly recorded and transcribed through Equitas, and a candidate can request the transcript.

Ties are broken by a predetermined area, usually Professional Knowledge. The document gives the worked example: two candidates both score 421 across the areas and tie at third on the panel; one scored 69 in Professional Knowledge and the other 68, so they are placed 3a and 3b. If that also ties, a third area is applied. The HSE interview questions guide covers the competencies this is applied to.

County and city councils: 50 per cent of the marks in each competency

Local authority booklets share one rule: “Candidates must achieve a minimum 50% of the total marks available in each of the competencies to qualify for inclusion on a panel.” That sentence, or one almost identical, appears in Kildare’s Staff Officer and Administrative Officer booklets, Limerick’s Senior Staff Officer booklet and Galway’s Executive Engineer booklet in 2026. What varies is whether the marks are published. Limerick does: 200 marks each for Delivering Results, Performance Through People, Personal Effectiveness and Management and Change at Grade VI, so 800 in total and 100 needed in each. For technical grades Limerick weights the sheet, with 300 marks for Relevant Knowledge and Experience against 100 for each of the other three. Dublin City Council, Kildare and Wexford say marks are awarded under the competencies without stating the numbers; Tipperary provides them on written request.

Two council particulars. Local Government Knowledge is a scored competency at most grades, so a candidate who knows nothing about the council’s budget, its reserved and executive functions or the number of councillors can fail an interview their STAR answers would have passed; the county council interview guide has the checklist. And some councils add marks for Irish: Galway County Council’s Grade V booklet gives an additional 3 or 6 per cent of the marks attained at the main interview for proficiency in Irish, assessed separately; the Irish tests for council competitions are run by publicjobs. Check your own booklet, because not every council offers it.

Garda Trainee and Recruit Prison Officer: order of merit, mark not published

The 2026 booklets for both competitions describe a competency-based interview and a role play over Zoom, name the competencies (five for Garda Trainee: Interpersonal Skills and Service Ethos, Exercising Authority, Conscientiousness, Resilience, Using Information and Problem Solving; six for Prison Officer: Directing Others, Supporting Others, Conscientiousness, Adaptability, Resilience, Information Handling and Communication) and state that successful candidates are placed on an order of merit. Neither booklet publishes the marks per competency or the pass mark. Candidates do see them afterwards: a Prison Officer candidate in 2025 reported an average of 32 out of 50 across the competencies, interview scores of 35 to 37, and a pass mark of 20, with the scores sent out with the result. Treat that as one candidate’s report, not the published rule. The Garda Trainee and Prison Officer guides cover what the role play tests.

How a board gets from your answer to a number

Boards are trained on the same method across these employers, and the Northern Ireland Civil Service publishes its training handout, which is the clearest public statement of it. The lead question is written around the main verb of the competency, in the past tense, asking for one example. The board then settles on that example and probes down through it: what you did, why, what you were thinking, what you learned. The handout’s own phrase for what probing does to a borrowed story is that it makes “the wheels fall off”. Under each competency the sheet lists positive and negative evidence. For a quality-service competency the positive list includes setting clear performance measures and establishing what customers need; the negative list includes showing little concern for improvement and treating the customer as a hindrance. Your mark is where the evidence you gave lands between those lists.

Three warnings in the training material are worth knowing. Boards are told to beware of first impressions and of “highly-articulate candidates” who impress in the room but whose evidence is thin on review. They are told that their notes must support the marks, with no vague adjectives or judgemental comments, which is why feedback can read as flat. And they are told not to react to answers: “Thank you for that” in a business-like tone, never “That’s great”. A board that gives you nothing back is doing its job, not marking you down.

What this means for your answers

Every competency needs its own evidence, because every competency is scored and passed on its own. A story told in “we” gives the board nothing to score under your name; the probe “what was your part exactly” exists to find out. An example from a grade below the one you are applying for caps at Potential or Acceptable however well it is told, because the band words say “at the level required”. A result with a figure moves you up a band more reliably than anything else, because it is the positive evidence the sheet is looking for. And the question boards ask almost as standard, what did you learn, is on the HSE probe list and in the Capability Framework’s result stage; its absence is noted. The STAR method examples show twelve answers with the band each would land in and why.

If you think the marking was wrong

Feedback comes first and is separate from any review. Under the CPSA Code you can ask the recruiting body to explain the basis of the decision, and the Code expects that explanation to be “clear, specific and meaningful”. If you believe a decision was made on incorrect information or that the documented procedure was not followed, a Section 7 review is available, informal within five working days of the decision and formal within five working days of the decision or the informal outcome. A Section 8 complaint is for an unfair process rather than a wrong decision, and can be appealed to the CPSA. A reviewer does not re-mark you; the role is to check the procedure was followed and the decision made on correct and full information. The order of merit, panels and review guide sets out the deadlines.

Questions people ask

Will I see my marks?

It depends on the employer. The HSE sends every candidate the marking sheet with scores and comments alongside the result letter. Councils vary: Kilkenny gives each competency score and the board comments, Kildare tells panelled candidates their marks and position, Tipperary provides marks on written request. publicjobs provides feedback on written request through the recruitment unit named on the booklet; whether that includes a number per sub-dimension is not stated in any published document, though candidates do report receiving scores. Prison Officer candidates in 2025 received their competency scores with the result.

What is a pass?

One number per competency, and you need it in every competency. Capability Framework interviews: 22 out of 50 in each sub-dimension, with one Potential score of 18 to 21 tolerated. HSE: 40 out of 100, or 2 out of 5 on the smaller scale, in each area. Councils: 50 per cent of the marks available in each competency. Legacy Competency Model competitions run by departments have used 55 per cent. Garda Trainee and Prison Officer booklets do not publish the mark; a 2025 Prison Officer candidate reported a pass mark of 20 out of 50.

Can a strong answer in one area rescue a weak one?

No. Every scheme here requires the minimum in each area separately, and the HSE guide for board members says plainly that failing one area fails the interview. What a strong answer can do is add to your total, which decides your place on the panel once you have passed everywhere.

How are ties broken?

The HSE names a predetermined area in advance, usually Professional Knowledge, and the higher score there goes first; its documents give the worked example of two candidates tied at 421 split by 69 against 68 in that area. publicjobs ranks by total interview score and processes candidates in batches. Councils rank by total marks; some add an Irish-language bonus of 3 or 6 per cent of the interview marks, assessed separately.

Do boards mark delivery, nerves or accent?

Not on the sheet. publicjobs says the panel are only interested in the content of what you say and will not assess how comfortable you are on camera. Interviewer training goes further and warns boards against being over-impressed by articulate candidates whose evidence is thin when reviewed. The sheet has a space for evidence under each competency and nothing for presentation.

Sources

StarMethod.ie is an independent practice tool and is not affiliated with publicjobs.ie, the Public Appointments Service, the HSE, An Garda Síochána, the Irish Prison Service or any local authority. Check dates and figures against the current booklet for your competition.

More guides