GuidesGuides

STAR method examples: 12 worked answers for Irish public sector interviews, with what the board writes against each

A STAR example is only useful if you can see why it scores. These twelve answers cover the questions Irish boards ask most, at Clerical Officer, Executive Officer, HSE Grade V, council and Garda level, and after each one is the note a board member would write on the marking sheet.

StarMethod.ie · Published 13 October 2026 · 18 min read

A woman pinning handwritten sticky notes to a white wall
Photo: Kaboompics, Pexels

How to read these examples

Each answer below is written for a named grade and marked against the published indicators for that grade: the Civil Service Capability Framework for Clerical Officer and Executive Officer, the HSE job specification headings for Grade V, Staff Nurse and Healthcare Assistant, the LGMA competencies as printed in council booklets, and the five Garda Trainee competency descriptors. The note after each answer is the kind of thing a board member writes on the sheet, followed by where the answer sits on the scale that board uses.

Two things to notice as you read. First, the Situation is short in every one of them, two sentences at most, because boards write nothing against it. Second, the Action is mostly sentences that start with “I” and name a specific thing done. That is where the indicators get ticked. The STAR method guide explains the structure itself; this page is the structure in use.

The spoken length of each is about two minutes. If yours run to four, the Situation is almost always the reason.

Teamwork and working with others

1. Tell me about a time you worked as part of a team to get something done.

Clerical Officer, Civil Service. Capability Framework: Communicating and Collaborating.

SLast spring I was a temporary Clerical Officer in a Social Welfare office with a team of five on the public counter. The office moved to a new appointment system over one weekend and the Monday queue was the longest anyone had seen.

TMy job that week was the same as everyone’s, to process the people in front of me, but the supervisor asked the five of us to sort out between ourselves how to get the queue down without the error rate going up.

AI suggested we split the queue into people with appointments and people without, because the people without were taking twice as long and holding up the ones who had done what we asked. Two colleagues disagreed at first; they felt walk-ins would feel pushed aside. I listened and we agreed a compromise: one desk for walk-ins, four for appointments, and I would swap onto the walk-in desk every hour so nobody was stuck on it all day. I made a one-page sheet of the five questions we were asked most often about the new system and put a copy on every desk. When a colleague got a difficult case I had seen before, I took it rather than let her start from scratch.

RBy Wednesday the queue was back to normal. The supervisor kept the two-queue split and the question sheet, and the sheet was later used for the next office in the region to switch. Nobody on the team had to stay late that week.

RWhat I learned was that the colleagues who disagreed with me were right about the walk-ins, and the compromise was better than my first idea. I would now ask the team first and suggest second.

What the board writes. Collaboration, Teamwork and Building Relationships: plays their part, works well with team members (took the difficult case, hourly rotation). Effective Communication: clear and helpful in writing (the question sheet). Engaging, Including and Listening: takes on board the views of others (changed the plan after colleagues disagreed). Level fit is CO: contributing to how a team works, not directing it. On the 1 to 50 scale this is a Pass in the Good band, around 28 to 32. What would lift it is a result with a number in it: how many people a day, how long the queue was before and after.

2. Give me an example of a time you had to address a performance issue in your team.

HSE Grade V, Staff Officer. Job specification heading: Team Working.

SIn 2025 I was acting Grade V over a team of four Grade IIIs in a hospital outpatients department. One of the four had been with us six months and was consistently the slowest at booking clinics, and two colleagues had started to complain to me about picking up her work.

TI had to bring her output up to the team standard without losing her, because the department was already two posts down, and I had to do it in a way that was fair and that the other three could see was being dealt with.

AI started by pulling the booking figures for all four for the previous eight weeks, so I was dealing with numbers rather than complaints. I met her one to one, showed her the figures without comparing her to anyone by name, and asked what was slowing her down. It turned out she had never been shown the shortcut keys in the patient system and was doing every booking through menus. I sat with her for half an hour on each of the next three days, then asked an experienced Grade III to be her go-to for questions for a month, which also gave that colleague some recognition. I agreed a target with her, reviewed it with her every Friday for six weeks, and told the other two, without detail, that the issue was being addressed. I kept a short note of each meeting.

RHer bookings went from about 60 per cent of the team average to just under the average in five weeks. The complaints stopped. When a permanent Grade V post came up she was one of the people who gave me a reference for the job.

RWhat I learned is to look at the data before the conversation. I had assumed attitude; it was training. I would now check how every new starter has been shown the system in their first fortnight, rather than find out at six months.

What the board writes. Team Working at Grade V: leads the team by example, coaching and supporting individuals (the three half-hours, the buddy); addresses performance issues as they arise (the one-to-one, the weekly review); develops clear and realistic objectives (the agreed target). Also evidence under Evaluating Information (pulled eight weeks of figures first). On the HSE 1 to 100 scale this is Good, around 75 to 80: a specific example at the right level with a measured result. A board might probe how the other two were told and what the note of each meeting contained.

Working under pressure and organising work

3. Describe a time you had to deliver under real time pressure. What did you prioritise and why?

Executive Officer, Civil Service. Capability Framework: Delivering Excellence.

SIn my current role as EO in a licensing unit, a court decision in March 2026 meant about 1,100 licences had to be re-issued with amended conditions within 20 working days, on top of the normal workload for a team of three Clerical Officers and me.

TI was responsible for getting all 1,100 out correctly inside the 20 days while keeping our normal turnaround on new applications inside its 10-day target, because the Minister had been asked about both in the Dáil.

AOn day one I sorted the 1,100 by licence type, because 800 were a single type where the amendment was identical and could be done as a batch mail merge from the database. I asked our IT contact that morning to confirm the export was possible and had it by day three. The remaining 300 needed individual checking, so I did a sample of 20 myself to write a one-page checking guide, then split them across the three COs at 15 a day each. I moved new applications to the mornings and re-issues to the afternoons so neither queue stopped. I set up a shared tracker with a daily count and looked at it with the team at 4.30 each day. On day eight we were 60 behind on the individual ones, so I went to my HEO with the tracker and asked for one CO from another unit for a week, which she agreed. I spot-checked one in ten of the finished re-issues.

RAll 1,100 went out by day 18. New applications stayed inside the 10-day target throughout; the longest was nine days. The spot-checks found four errors in the first week and none in the second, after I went back over the guide with the team. The checking guide is now the standard document for amendments in the unit.

RI learned to go for help with figures in hand early. I had the tracker from day one and should have used it on day five rather than day eight. If I did it again I would also ask IT about the batch option before I sorted anything, since that decision shaped the whole plan.

What the board writes. Managing Work Effectively: manages, plans and prioritises workload to ensure deadlines are met (the sort by type, the morning and afternoon split); has oversight of the team’s work and puts procedures in place to track quality and productivity (tracker, spot-checks, 4.30 review). Delivering Quality Outcomes: excellent attention to detail and accuracy (sample of 20, checking guide, error count). Attitude, Initiative and Flexibility: resilience under pressure, seeking support when needed. Level is EO: organising other people’s work and escalating with evidence. Pass, high in the Good band, around 32 to 34 of 50. Very Good would need the board to hear something going wrong and being recovered, which the day-eight escalation only partly gives.

4. Tell us about a shift where you had more to do than time to do it. How did you manage?

Healthcare Assistant, HSE. Job specification heading: Planning and Organising.

SI work nights in a 30-bed nursing home, usually two HCAs and one nurse. One night in January the other HCA went home sick at 11 and no replacement could be found, so it was me and the nurse for 30 residents until seven.

TMy job was to get every resident who needed turning turned on time, everyone who needed pads changed changed, and the two residents on hourly checks checked every hour, without the nurse having to leave her medication round to cover me.

AI went through the handover sheet with the nurse at 11.15 and we agreed who were the priorities: the two on hourly checks, the six who needed two-hourly turns, and one resident who was at risk of falling and tended to get up around three. I wrote the times on a sheet and ticked them off as I went, because I knew by five I would not trust my memory. I did the turns in the order of the corridor so I was not walking back and forth. I asked the nurse to do the two residents who needed two people with me at one and at four, when her round was quietest, instead of whenever I got to them. When the resident at risk of falling got up at ten to three I sat with him for ten minutes rather than rushing him back, because rushing him is what causes the falls. I told the nurse every hour where I was on the list.

REveryone was turned within 15 minutes of their time, the hourly checks were all done and recorded, and there were no falls and no skin marks on the morning check. The nurse wrote in the night report that the shift had been covered safely, and the day CNM asked me to show the new HCAs the tick-sheet idea.

RI learned that writing the times down and agreeing the order with the nurse at the start is worth the ten minutes, even on a normal night. I now do it on every shift.

What the board writes. Planning and Organising, as the 2026 HCA specification words it: the ability to plan and complete own work (the timed sheet, the corridor order); the ability to work on own initiative (the 11.15 plan, the ten minutes with the resident); a flexible approach to work. Also strong evidence under Quality and Patient Focus (no falls, no skin marks) and Communication (hourly update to the nurse). Scored against the HCA headings this is Good, around 75 to 85 of 100: a candidate who shows judgement, not just effort, and whose result is checkable. A board would probe what was left undone and whether anything was reported upward.

Dealing with a difficult person

5. Tell me about a time you dealt with an angry or upset customer.

Council Grade III, Clerical Officer. LGMA competency: Customer Service and Communication Skills.

SI worked on the housing counter of a county council for 14 months. A man came in whose rent arrears letter had arrived the same morning as a notice that his rent had been reassessed upwards, and he thought the two were the same thing and that he was about to be evicted.

TI had to find out what had actually happened on his account, explain it to him in a way he could take in while he was angry, and not promise anything that the housing officer, not me, had the power to decide.

AI asked him to sit down at the side desk rather than stand at the counter, because there was a queue behind him and he was getting louder. I let him finish before I said anything. Then I said back to him what I had understood, that he thought the arrears letter was an eviction notice, and he corrected one detail, which calmed him down because he could see I was listening. I pulled up the account and showed him the two letters were about different things: the arrears were €340 from a payment that had bounced in December, and the reassessment was because his son had started work. I explained what each letter asked him to do and by when. He asked me to cancel the reassessment; I told him I could not, but I could book him an appointment with the housing officer that week and give him the form to declare the son’s actual hours. I wrote the appointment and the arrears figure on a slip for him.

RHe left with the appointment and the form and thanked me on the way out. He came back on the Thursday with the form filled in. I checked with the housing officer afterwards: the reassessment was reduced because the son was part-time, and he set up a plan for the €340. No complaint was made.

RWhat I took from it was to move someone out of the queue early. I had waited a minute too long hoping he would settle, and the queue made it worse for him and for me.

What the board writes. Customer Service and Communication Skills: actively listens and tries to understand the customer’s perspective (let him finish, repeated it back); understands that procedures apply and can clearly explain them (two letters, two actions); respectful and composed in challenging circumstances; can be firm when necessary (could not cancel the reassessment). On the council scale, where a candidate needs 50 per cent of the marks in each competency to make the panel, this is well above the line, in the upper third. A board might ask what he said that was hardest to hear, and how the candidate felt afterwards: that is the composure indicator being checked.

6. Describe a situation where you had to use tact and diplomacy with a patient’s family.

Staff Nurse, HSE. Job specification heading: Building and Maintaining Relationships.

SOn a surgical ward last year I was looking after a woman in her eighties on day two after a hip repair. Her daughter arrived at visiting time, found her mother drowsy and in pain, and told me loudly at the nurses’ station that we were neglecting her.

TI needed to take the daughter’s concern seriously, deal with the pain, and explain what was happening without breaching the patient’s confidentiality in a corridor full of other visitors.

AI asked the daughter to come with me to her mother’s bedside rather than talk at the station, so we were speaking where her mother could hear and consent. I checked the patient first: her pain score was six, her last analgesia was four hours earlier and the next dose was due, so I gave it and told them both when it would start working. I then sat down, which I find changes the tone, and asked the daughter what she had expected to see on day two. She had expected her mother up and walking. I explained the plan: physio that afternoon, the drowsiness from the analgesia, what we were watching for. I asked the patient if she was happy for me to go through the chart with her daughter, and she was. I showed the daughter the pain score record and the turning chart. I told her the name of the CNM and that she could ask for her at any time. I documented the conversation and told the CNM at the next handover.

RThe daughter apologised for shouting before she left and asked what time physio was so she could come back for it. There was no complaint. The patient was mobilising with a frame the next day.

RI learned to bring the conversation to the bedside sooner. I had started answering at the station out of habit and that is where confidentiality goes wrong. I also now ask every family on day one what they expect the first days to look like, because the gap between expectation and reality is what produces that kind of anger.

What the board writes. Building and Maintaining Relationships: uses diplomacy and tact in fraught situations and can diffuse tense situations comfortably (the move to the bedside, sitting down); demonstrates awareness and appreciation of the patient and their families; ensures care is carried out in an empathetic and ethical manner (consent before sharing the chart). Also evidence under Commitment to Providing a Quality Service (records up to date, CNM informed) and Communication (anticipates emotional reactions). HSE scale: Good, around 78 to 85. The consent step and the documentation are what separate this from an Adequate answer; most candidates leave both out.

A mistake, a failure, a decision

7. Tell me about a mistake you made at work and what you did about it.

Clerical Officer, Civil Service. Capability Framework: Building Future Readiness (openly sharing and learning from mistakes).

SIn my first month as a CO in a payments section I was entering bank details for new payees. I transposed two digits in one account number and the payment, €1,240, went to the wrong account.

TOnce I spotted it, two days later while checking a different file, I had to report it, get the money recovered, and make sure I did not do it again.

AI went to my EO straight away, before I had worked out whether it could be fixed quietly, because I knew the longer it sat the harder recovery would be. I brought the file and the two account numbers so she could see exactly what had happened. She showed me the recall procedure and I drafted the recall request to the bank myself, which she checked and sent. I rang the payee to explain the delay and tell him the correct payment would issue that day, which it did. Then I asked the EO if I could change how I checked my own entries: I started reading every account number back from the screen against the form digit by digit before saving, and for the first month I asked a colleague to double-check any payment over €1,000.

RThe bank recovered the €1,240 within nine working days. The payee got his money the same day I rang him and did not complain. I made no further entry errors in the following eleven months, and the read-back check is something I still do.

RWhat I learned is that the worst part of a mistake is the two days before you report it. The EO said afterwards that she rated me for coming straight in, and I have taken that into how I would want a new colleague to treat me.

What the board writes. Openness to change: willing to try new approaches, seeking support when needed and openly sharing and learning from their mistakes, almost word for word. Delivering Quality Outcomes and Service: actively seeks support and checks of their work to ensure high standards (the read-back, the colleague check). Attitude, Ownership and Flexibility: takes ownership and responsibility over work. Informed Judgement: follows the relevant procedure (recall), refers upward. A board will like this answer more than a candidate expects: Pass, around 30 of 50. The one risk is tone. A candidate who sounds proud of the mistake, or who blames the form, loses the credit; this one does neither.

8. Give me an example of a decision you had to make with incomplete information.

Executive Officer, Civil Service. Capability Framework: Managing Information, Problems and Decisions.

SAs an EO in a grants section in 2025, I had a file where an applicant had sent the required accounts for the wrong year. The closing date for the scheme was in three days and the correct accounts were with his accountant, who was on leave for a week.

TI had to decide whether to accept the application as complete, reject it, or find a third route, knowing that a rejection on a technicality would likely become a representation to the Minister and an acceptance without the right documents would fail audit.

AI read the scheme circular again to see exactly what it required: it said accounts for the most recent financial year had to be “furnished before a decision is made”, not before the closing date. That was the gap. I checked the previous year’s file for the same applicant, which showed he had been compliant for six years. I rang him, confirmed the correct accounts existed and were only delayed, and asked for an email from the accountant confirming they would be sent within ten days. I then put a one-paragraph note on the file setting out the circular wording, the compliance history, the accountant’s email and my decision to accept the application as received but to hold the decision until the accounts arrived, and I sent that note to my HEO for information rather than approval, because it was within my remit. I diarised the ten days.

RThe accounts arrived on day seven, the application was assessed on the normal timeline and approved. At the internal audit sample that autumn the file was picked and passed, with the note specifically mentioned as good practice. The HEO asked me to write the approach up as a two-line guidance note for the section.

RI learned to read the actual words of the circular before deciding anything. My first instinct was that the closing date was absolute, and it was not. I would do the same again, and I would get the note on the file before the phone call rather than after.

What the board writes. Gathering and Processing Information: gathers, understands and analyses information from a range of sources (circular, file history, accountant). Informed Judgement and Decision Making: balanced judgement considering available information, previous learnings and the relevant procedure; makes decisions within own remit, keeping the HEO informed. Problem Solving: identifies and solves a complex problem. Level is EO, exactly: a judgement call inside a defined remit, with the audit trail to show it. Pass, Good band, about 31 to 33 of 50. Very Good would need the decision to have been contested and defended.

Change, initiative and learning

9. Tell me about a change you introduced in your area and how you brought people with you.

Council Grade V, Staff Officer. LGMA competency: Management and Change.

SAs acting Staff Officer in a motor tax office in 2025 I had six staff and a paper-based system for logging the post that came in each morning, around 200 items, which took one person most of the morning and meant nobody could say where an item was until it was logged.

TI wanted to move the logging onto the shared drive with a scanner, which the Director had agreed in principle, but two of the six had been there over twenty years and had told me plainly that the paper book worked fine.

AI started with those two. I asked them to walk me through the paper system and what they liked about it, and I learned that the real value was the handwritten note of who had taken each item, which the drive version did not have. So I added a column for it. I ran the two systems side by side for two weeks, with the two experienced staff doing the paper book and a newer colleague doing the scan, and compared the time and the queries each morning. I shared the comparison at the Friday team meeting, including the one morning the scanner jammed and the paper book won. I asked the two sceptics to write the one-page how-to for the new system, because they knew what a new person would get wrong. I told the Senior Executive Officer where we were each week and gave him a date for switching over.

RWe switched after three weeks. Logging went from most of a morning for one person to about 45 minutes, and the counter staff could answer “where is my form” queries by searching the drive instead of asking around. Six months later the Director asked me to help the planning office do the same. One of the two sceptics now trains new starters on it.

RI learned that the resistance was about something real, the handwritten note, and once that was in the new system the argument was over. I would start by asking what people would lose, not by explaining what they would gain.

What the board writes. Management and Change: creates opportunities for new ways of working and overcomes resistance to change (the side-by-side trial, the column for the note, giving the sceptics the how-to); develops and maintains positive relationships with staff; translates objectives into operational plans and monitors progress (weekly updates, a switch date). Also Performance through People: leads and engages staff. Level fits Staff Officer: running a team’s way of working and reporting upward. Comfortably above the 50 per cent line, in the top band of the council scale. A board would probe the Director’s role to check the candidate did the work rather than carried out instructions.

10. Give your best example of using technology or a digital solution to address a challenge.

Executive Officer, Civil Service. Capability Framework: Building Future Readiness (digital focus).

SIn my section we processed about 400 queries a month by email, and the same ten questions made up roughly half of them. Each reply was typed from scratch, and the answers were not always the same from one CO to the next.

TI set myself the task of cutting the time spent on repeat queries and making the answers consistent, without buying anything or waiting for an IT project.

AI pulled a month of sent emails and categorised them in a spreadsheet, which is how I knew it was ten questions and half the volume. I wrote a model answer for each of the ten, had each one checked by my HEO for accuracy, and set them up as shared templates in Outlook so every CO had the same wording. I made a one-page decision list: if the query says X, use template 3. I ran a half-hour session with the four COs, then checked a sample of 30 sent replies a week later to see whether the templates were being used and whether they were being edited sensibly. Two templates were being edited every time, so I rewrote them. I kept the spreadsheet going for three more months to see whether the mix of questions changed.

RTime on the ten repeat queries fell from about 12 minutes to about 3 each, which over 200 queries a month was roughly 30 hours of CO time. Replies became consistent, which the HEO had been asked about after two customers compared answers. The templates are still used and were adopted by the neighbouring section.

RI learned that the categorising step was the whole project: once the numbers were visible, nobody argued. I would do the sample check at a week again, because without it two of the templates would have quietly been abandoned.

What the board writes. Digital Focus: maximises the use of technology and digital skills to drive efficiencies and support better service delivery. Innovation and Creative Solutions: actively puts forward helpful suggestions. Managing Work Effectively: puts procedures in place to track quality (the sample of 30). The candidate did not build anything clever, which is fine; the indicator is about using what is there. Pass, around 30 to 32 of 50. The 30 hours figure is the kind of result that gets written down; “it saved a lot of time” would not be.

Uniformed services: authority and resilience

11. Tell us about a time you had to take charge of a situation and make a decision other people did not like.

Garda Trainee. Competency: Exercising Authority.

SI was the senior lifeguard on a beach in Clare for the summer of 2025. On a bank holiday Monday the wind swung onshore after lunch and a rip developed at the north end where about forty people were in the water.

TI had to decide whether to close that end of the beach, which meant moving forty people on the busiest day of the year with two junior guards and a lot of families who had just settled in.

AI called it within a minute of seeing the rip form, because waiting to see if it settled would have meant acting with people already in trouble. I radioed the two juniors to put up the red flags at the north end and told them exactly what to say: the water is unsafe here, please move to the flagged area, it is not optional. I walked the waterline myself and spoke to each group, starting with the ones furthest out. Three men in their twenties argued that they were strong swimmers. I told them that I was not asking, that I would be calling the Coast Guard if they went back in, and that the flagged area was 200 metres away. I did not raise my voice and I did not stay to argue; I moved on to the next group and let them see I meant it. I logged the time, the decision and the reason in the incident book while it was fresh, and told the beach supervisor by phone.

RThe north end was clear in about twelve minutes. The three men moved. Nobody went into the rip, and there were no rescues that afternoon on a day when two neighbouring beaches had them. The supervisor backed the decision and it was discussed at the end-of-season review as the right call.

RI learned that the decision is easier than the standing over it, and that the standing over it is done by being calm and not negotiating. If I did it again I would brief the juniors on the exact words before the season, not over the radio in the moment.

What the board writes. Exercising Authority: the descriptor asks for “the self-assurance to make rapid, well-judged and potentially unpopular decisions, executing them and standing by them”. The answer evidences all four: rapid (within a minute), well-judged (the reasoning about waiting), unpopular (the three men), stood by (did not negotiate, logged it). It also touches Conscientiousness (incident book, told the supervisor) and Resilience (calm under challenge). Garda boards do not publish their marks per competency; candidates report placings on an order of merit. The probes to expect: what would you have done if the three men had gone back in, and what did the supervisor say.

12. Describe a time you stayed professional when someone was trying to provoke you.

Recruit Prison Officer. Competency: Resilience.

SI worked door security at a late bar in Limerick for two years. One night a man I had refused entry for being drunk came back twice over an hour, the second time with two friends, and spent about ten minutes shouting at me in front of a queue, including things about my family.

TMy job was to keep the door, keep the queue safe and not give him the reaction he was looking for, because a reaction from me would have been on three phones and would have ended my job and possibly his night in a cell.

AI kept my hands where he could see them and stood side-on to him, which I was trained to do and which also made it harder for him to square up. I answered the same way each time he came at me: you are not coming in tonight, you can come back another night, I would like you to move away from the door. I did not answer anything he said about my family and I did not make eye contact with his friends, because I did not want to make it a group thing. I radioed the inside team so they knew what was happening and I asked the queue, calmly, to step back a little. When he moved towards me I stepped back rather than towards him and said once that if he touched me or anyone in the queue I would be calling the Gardaí. I did not touch him at any point.

RHis friends pulled him away after about ten minutes. Nothing was thrown and nobody in the queue was hurt. The manager reviewed the camera the next day and said there was nothing he would have done differently. The man came back a fortnight later, sober, and was let in without an issue.

RI learned that I do not need to win the exchange, I need to end the shift with nothing having happened. I noticed afterwards that my hands were shaking, which I had not felt at the time, and I spoke to a more experienced colleague about it. That is where the calm comes from: knowing it is normal to feel it after.

What the board writes. Resilience, as the booklet defines it: “manages stress and controls their emotions to ensure they act appropriately in routine as well as in challenging situations” and “has sufficient self-assurance and clarity about their own and the Service’s values to resist pressures to act unprofessionally”. Both are evidenced, and the last paragraph, admitting the shaking hands and talking to a colleague, is the kind of self-awareness boards credit. Prison Officer candidates in the 2025 competition reported scores out of 50 per competency with the pass mark at 20 and the 30s described as a good interview; this answer sits in the 30s. Probes: what would you have done if he had touched you, and have you ever got it wrong.

What the twelve have in common

If you want the questions themselves, the 50 STAR interview questions guide groups them by competency with the follow-up each one brings. The marking sheets guide explains the scales these notes refer to.

Questions people ask

Are these STAR examples real answers from candidates?

No. Each one is written to show the shape of an answer that scores, at the grade named, against the published indicators. The situations are ordinary public sector work, which is the point: boards mark behaviour, not drama. Use them as patterns for your own stories, not as scripts.

Can I use an example from outside work?

Yes. publicjobs tells candidates to draw on "education, work, interests, etc." and Garda and Prison Officer boards expect examples from sport, volunteering and family life. The board marks what you did and why, not where it happened. The one caution is level: an example has to show the behaviour at the grade you are applying for.

How many STAR examples do I need?

publicjobs suggests "about 10 different achievements altogether". In practice eight strong stories, each able to serve two competencies, cover a Civil Service, HSE or council interview. Boards notice the same story used three times and some ask for "a second, different example" on the spot.

Should I add a reflection after the Result?

Yes. Irish boards probe for it: "What would you say you learned?" and "What would you do differently?" are among the most reported follow-ups in 2026. publicjobs own STAR guidance ends Result with "explain what you learned from the experience". One or two sentences, written in advance.

What if my result was not a success?

Say so. A mixed or failed result with an honest account of what you changed afterwards scores better than a perfect result the board does not believe. Interviewer training warns boards that probing is how "the wheels fall off" an inflated story; a candid one has nothing to fall off.

Sources

StarMethod.ie is an independent practice tool and is not affiliated with publicjobs.ie, the Public Appointments Service, the HSE, An Garda Síochána, the Irish Prison Service or any local authority. Check dates and figures against the current booklet for your competition.

More guides