GuidesGuides

Verbal reasoning True, False or Cannot Say: the four traps in publicjobs passages and how to read past them

The verbal reasoning test in publicjobs competitions is not a reading test. It is a test of whether you can stop yourself adding what you know to what the passage says. Most wrong answers are False where the passage is silent, or True where the statement quietly widened a claim. This guide names the four traps, shows each one on a short passage, and gives a routine for the thirty seconds you have per statement.

StarMethod.ie · Published 20 October 2026 · 10 min read

Hands highlighting lines of a printed document with a pen and a pink highlighter
Photo: Kaboompics, Pexels

The verbal reasoning test in publicjobs competitions gives you a short passage in the register of a circular or a policy note, then four or five statements to mark True, False or Cannot Say. Candidates who sat the HEO version in October 2026 said the hard part was not the reading. It was that “False or Cannot Say are often unclear”. They are not unclear; they are decided by a rule most people have never been told. This guide states the rule, shows the four ways the statements are built to make you break it, and gives a routine that fits in the time you have.

The rule

A statement is True if the passage says it or it follows directly from what the passage says. It is False if the passage says the opposite, or states an exception that defeats it. Everything else is Cannot Say, including statements you know to be true from your own job, statements that are probably true, and statements the passage comes close to but never actually makes. The test is not asking whether the statement is true. It is asking whether this passage supports it. For the thirty seconds you spend on each statement, the passage is the only document in the world.

Most wrong answers break the rule in one direction: False given to a statement the passage never addressed. The passage is silent, the statement sounds wrong, and the candidate marks False. The second most common is True given to a statement that quietly widened what the passage said. The four traps below are the ways the test engineers both.

Trap 1: the scope shift

Under the department’s records policy, the Records Officer and two named deputies may authorise the destruction of files that have passed their retention date. Files relating to live litigation are excluded from destruction regardless of retention date. All destruction requests are logged centrally and the log is reviewed each quarter.

Only the Records Officer and the Records Officer’s staff may authorise the destruction of files. Cannot Say

The passage names the Records Officer and two deputies. The statement replaces “two named deputies” with “the Records Officer’s staff”. Are the deputies on the Records Officer’s staff? Probably, in real life. The passage does not say so. The group in the statement is not the group in the passage, so the passage cannot confirm it. Watch for a noun that has been swapped for a wider or narrower one: “staff” for “deputies”, “the unit” for “the team”, “applicants” for “successful applicants”.

A file that has passed its retention date is always destroyed. False

The litigation exception is in the text. The passage states a case where a file past its date is not destroyed, so “always” is defeated by the passage itself. This is False, not Cannot Say.

Trap 2: the absolute word

Most applications under the scheme are decided within six weeks of receipt. Applications that require a site inspection are not decided within six weeks. In 2025 around a fifth of applications required an inspection.

All applications are decided within six weeks. False

“Most” became “all”, and the passage names the applications that take longer. The words to circle in any statement are all, every, only, always, never, solely, none. When the passage used most, some, usually, tend to, often, the absolute version is either False (if the passage names the exception) or Cannot Say (if it merely implies one).

In 2025 roughly one application in five was not decided within six weeks. True

Two sentences chained: inspections are not decided within six weeks, and about a fifth required inspection. The statement follows directly. True does not need the exact words; it needs a chain of the passage’s own sentences with no link added from outside.

Trap 3: the motive leap

The unit stopped publishing its monthly bulletin in March. Visits to the unit’s web page fell by 30 per cent between March and June. In July the unit launched a quarterly report in place of the bulletin.

Visits to the web page fell because the bulletin stopped. Cannot Say

The passage gives two facts in sequence. It does not say one caused the other. Candidates mark True because the inference is obvious, and the inference may well be right; the passage still has not made it. “Because”, “in order to”, “as a result”, “which shows that” in a statement are the signal: find the sentence in the passage that states the cause. If there is none, Cannot Say.

The quarterly report replaced the monthly bulletin. True

“In place of” is “replaced”. Stated.

Trap 4: the exception

All grant payments are made by electronic transfer, with the exception of payments to recipients who have asked for a cheque on medical grounds. Payments above €10,000 require a second authorising signature regardless of the method of payment.

Every grant payment is made by electronic transfer. False

The passage opened with “all” and then took some back. Statements built on the first half of a sentence are the commonest False in these tests: the candidate remembers the headline and not the clause after the comma. Read to the full stop before you decide.

A cheque payment of €12,000 requires a second signature. True

“Regardless of the method” covers cheques; €12,000 is above €10,000. Both links are in the text.

Recipients who request a cheque must provide medical evidence. Cannot Say

Grounds are mentioned; evidence is not. A procedure you would expect is not a procedure the passage described.

A routine for thirty seconds

  1. Read the passage once, properly, before any statement. Note where the numbers and the exceptions are. Do not try to remember it; you will come back.
  2. For each statement, find the one or two sentences in the passage it depends on. Read only those.
  3. Ask in order: does the passage say this or does it follow from two of its sentences? True. Does the passage say the opposite, or name an exception that defeats it? False. Neither? Cannot Say, and stop thinking.
  4. Circle the trigger words before you answer: absolutes (all, only, always, never), causes (because, as a result, so that), swapped nouns, half-sentences with a clause you have not checked.
  5. When you notice you are reasoning from what you know about how departments work, that is the answer: Cannot Say.

On a timed EO paper this is about 30 seconds a statement. On Sova there is no countdown, but your time is scored, and candidates in October aimed at about a minute a question. The routine is the same; what changes is that on Sova there is no clock to tell you that you have been re-reading the passage for the fourth time.

Practising it

Naming the trap is most of the cure, and it only works if you name it on your own misses. For each wrong answer, write down which of the four it was. After two or three passages the list usually has one entry repeated, and that is the habit to carry into the test. The Stage 1 trainer has thirty passages and 120 statements in the circular register, each statement tagged with the trap it sets, with the governing sentence quoted in the key, and a pattern report that names your dominant confusion. The first passage is free. The companion guides cover the situational judgement test, where the other block of Stage 1 marks sits, and what each grade sits at Stage 1.

Questions people ask

What does Cannot Say mean in a verbal reasoning test?

That the passage does not give you enough to decide either way. It is not a statement about the world. A statement can be true in real life and still be Cannot Say, because the test asks what the passage supports, not what you know. The most common wrong answer in these tests is False given to a statement the passage simply never addressed.

When is a statement False rather than Cannot Say?

When the passage says the opposite, or states an exception that defeats the statement. "All payments are electronic, except cheques on medical grounds" makes "Every payment is electronic" False, not Cannot Say, because the exception is in the text. If the passage is silent on the point, it is Cannot Say however unlikely the statement sounds.

Can I use my own knowledge?

No, and that is the whole test. The passages are written in a public sector register about schemes, records and procedures, and a Civil Service candidate often knows the real rule. The question is always whether this passage states or implies it. Treat the passage as the only document in the world for the thirty seconds you spend on each statement.

How long do I have per statement?

In EO 2026 the verbal test was 35 minutes for about 15 passages of four to five statements, roughly 30 seconds a statement after reading. On Sova (HEO, AO, AP) there is no countdown, but response time is recorded and forms part of the score, and candidates who sat it aimed at about a minute a question. In both cases re-reading the whole passage for every statement is the time sink to avoid.

Are the passages about the Civil Service?

Mostly about administration in general: records, payments, procedures, reports, staffing, scheme rules, in the style of a circular or a policy note. The subject knowledge does not help and sometimes hurts. The skills are locating the governing sentence quickly and refusing to add to it.

Does the trainer on this site tell me which trap I keep falling for?

Yes. Each statement in the bank is tagged with the trap it sets, and the pattern report under the tabs names the confusion that dominates your attempts once there is enough data, for example False where the text only supports Cannot Say. Thirty passages and 120 statements, the first passage free.

Sources

StarMethod.ie is an independent practice tool and is not affiliated with publicjobs.ie, the Public Appointments Service, the HSE, An Garda Síochána, the Irish Prison Service or any local authority. Check dates and figures against the current booklet for your competition.

More guides