The situational judgement test is the Stage 1 component people prepare for least and lose most on. Candidates on the EO 2026 and HEO 2026 threads report 600 to 750 out of 800 in verbal and numerical reasoning alongside 400 to 450 in situational judgement, and an Order of Merit position that would have been in the first hundred ends up outside the interview cut-off. The verbal and numerical tests measure skills a graduate has. The SJT measures something that has to be learned: what a person at this grade may decide, whom they must tell, and which actions the Civil Service treats as never acceptable whatever the intention behind them.
Two scales, one logic
Clerical Officer, Executive Officer, Garda Trainee and Prison Officer competitions rate each action on four points: Good, Adequate, Weak, Bad. HEO, AO and AP competitions on Sova use six, from Highly Appropriate down to Highly Inappropriate. The six-point scale is not a finer version of the four-point one. It separates “good but missing a step” (Appropriate) from “solves it completely within remit” (Highly Appropriate), and “well meant but premature” (Slightly Inappropriate) from “ignores the real problem or goes around your manager” (Inappropriate). The bottom rating is reserved for breaches: a rule, a law, the authority of the grade, or the dignity of a member of staff or the public.
Three mechanics come from the HEO 2026 familiarisation booklet and apply to the Sova tests. Each action is rated independently. Repeated ratings are allowed. There is no negative marking, and “correct and near-correct ratings receive credit”. The last point decides strategy: a rating one step off the key still earns, a rating at the wrong end earns nothing, so the expensive error is not being decisive, it is being timid about something that is clearly a breach.
The six rules behind the keys
publicjobs does not publish keys. But the tests are written against the Capability Framework for the grade and the rules civil servants work under, and almost every rating can be explained by one of six principles.
- Scope of the grade. Act on what sits in your remit and pass up what does not. A CO applies the scheme and escalates exceptions to the EO. An EO allocates work and fixes workflow but does not change eligibility or resourcing. A HEO manages EOs and operational delivery, reallocates tasks, checks evidence and proposes improvements; permanent staffing, budget moves between subheads, policy or eligibility changes and statutory decisions sit with the AP or above. Acting above your grade is a breach. Passing up what your grade should handle is passive, and rated below the middle.
- Chain of command. Keep your line manager informed. Do not go around them to a Principal Officer, a Minister’s office or an outside body unless they are unavailable and the deadline is now.
- Speak privately first. Conduct, sharpness and performance are raised with the person, in private, after you have the facts. A group email or an escalation before that conversation is premature.
- Evidence first. Check the file, the data or the procedure before promising an outcome, refusing a request or telling a Minister’s office anything.
- Compliance. Personal data, tax clearance, procurement thresholds, FOI deadlines, protected disclosures: these are not judgement calls. An action that breaches one is at the bottom of the scale however kind the motive.
- Service delivery. The public, the Minister and other units are owed accurate information on time. An action that leaves a caller or a deadline hanging while something else is sorted is incomplete, not neutral.
A worked scenario on the six-point scale
This scenario is written for the guide and is not in the practice bank. It is a HEO situation; an EO or AO version would shift what sits in remit, not the principles.
You are a Higher Executive Officer managing a grants unit of three EOs and eight COs. The quarterly processing target falls on Friday week. On Thursday afternoon one of your EOs tells you, in confidence, that a CO has been approving applications where the applicant’s tax clearance certificate is missing, telling applicants to “send it on later” so the files can be closed before the deadline. The EO has counted twelve such approvals in two weeks. The payment run for approved applications goes out on Monday morning. Your Assistant Principal is at a conference until the middle of next week and reachable by phone.
Rate each action independently.
A. Hold the twelve files out of Monday’s payment run, have the EO check each for the certificate, and email the AP today with what was found and what you have done.
6 · Highly Appropriate
Everything here is HEO remit: operational control of the unit’s output, checking evidence before money moves, directing an EO. The AP is informed the same day without being asked to decide an operational matter. Tax clearance is a statutory condition of payment, so the hold is not caution, it is compliance. Nothing is missing.
B. Let Monday’s payments go out, since the certificates will probably arrive, and raise the matter with the CO after the quarterly deadline.
1 · Highly Inappropriate
A statutory check is waived to protect a target. That is the definition of the bottom rating: a rule breached knowingly, with public money. The delay in speaking to the CO compounds it. Candidates who rate this Slightly Inappropriate because the intention was to meet a deadline lose the full mark for the action; the gap of two or three steps from the key earns nothing.
C. Send an email to the whole unit reminding everyone that tax clearance is mandatory before approval, without naming anyone.
4 · Slightly Appropriate
Not wrong, and a reasonable second step. But it does nothing about the twelve files that pay out on Monday, and it addresses a conduct issue with one person by broadcasting to eleven. Helpful in part, incomplete, and it delays the real fix. A rating of 3 here would be a near miss and earn partial credit; a 6 would not.
D. Phone the AP at the conference, explain what the EO has told you, and ask what they want you to do.
2 · Inappropriate
Telling the AP is right; asking the AP to decide is not. Holding files, checking certificates and speaking to a CO about process are the HEO’s decisions. Passing them up, with Monday’s run two working days away, leaves the core problem untouched while the manager is interrupted for something within your own authority. It is not a breach, so it is not the bottom rating, but it is the passive answer and the scale treats passivity below the middle.
E. Ask the EO to hold the twelve files for now, and speak to the CO privately first thing tomorrow to establish what happened before deciding anything further.
5 · Appropriate
Private first, evidence first, and the money is held. What is missing is the AP: a pattern of twelve approvals without a statutory document is something your manager hears about today, not after you have formed a view. One secondary step short of the top rating.
What the scenario teaches
Notice the shape of the key: 6, 1, 4, 2, 5. Two actions at the top, one at the bottom, two in between, and no two the same by accident rather than design. A candidate who “balances” their ratings would be right here by luck and wrong on the next scenario, where three actions might be Appropriate or better. Notice also where the marks were: the difference between a 1 and a 3 on action B is the difference between full credit and none, and the whole of that difference is one rule, that tax clearance is a legal condition and not a preference. Most SJT marks are like this. They are not won by being decisive or being kind; they are won by knowing which actions the rules take out of your hands.
The four-point scale, briefly
On the CO, EO and uniformed tests the same logic compresses to four steps. Good is an action that meets the situation within remit; Adequate is acceptable with an omission; Weak falls short, usually by being passive or premature; Bad is incompetent or a breach. Action A above would be Good, E Adequate, C and D Weak, B Bad. The compression removes the distinction between “missing a step” and “solves it completely”, which is why four-point practice is poor preparation for a six-point test and the trainer keeps the scales separate by grade.
How to practise
Commit to a rating for every action before you see any key. Read the explanation for every action you placed more than one step away, and name the principle you missed. After twenty or thirty scenarios the habit shows: softening breaches, over-escalating, spreading ratings. Then sit papers of ten in fifty minutes with no feedback until the end, because that is the test. The Stage 1 trainer has sixty six-point scenarios built on the circulars, six fixed papers of ten, and a pattern report that names the principle costing you most. The first scenario on each scale is free. The companion guides cover the verbal reasoning traps and what each grade sits at Stage 1.



