GuidesGuides

Competency-based application form examples: how to write the written example that gets you shortlisted

For HEO, AP, council Grade IV and up, and every HSE grade, the written example on the form is scored before anyone meets you. This guide shows what the shortlisting board is told to look for, the limits each body sets, and two examples rewritten from a draft that would not shortlist to one that would.

StarMethod.ie · Published 13 October 2026 · 14 min read

A hand filling in a printed form with a pen on a wooden table
Photo: RDNE Stock project, Pexels

Who reads it and what they are told to find

For Civil Service competitions at HEO and above, for council posts from Grade IV up, and for every HSE grade, the competency examples on the application form are assessed before anyone meets you. The HEO 2026 booklet describes it: an expert board examines the forms against agreed shortlisting criteria, and where the competition attracts a large number of eligible candidates, the process “will apply a scored assessment of the information provided on the application form” and rank candidates. Councils are blunter. Limerick City and County Council scores shortlisting per competency and warns that reaching 50 per cent in each “will not guarantee that a candidate is called for interview”, because only a proportion of those who pass are called, by shortlisting mark. The HSE tells applicants a selection board assesses the form against the eligibility criteria and the skills, competencies and knowledge section of the specification, and that applicants who are not shortlisted are told the reasons.

The shortlisting board has the same indicators the interview board will have, and the same instruction: look for evidence of the behaviour, at the level of the grade, in something the candidate actually did. The HSE’s guide to competency questions says it plainly: “The review team will not assume you demonstrate a skill just because of your role, length of service”; you need to do more than describe your current role and list important decisions, you need to describe how you reached them. Everything below follows from that sentence.

The limits, and what they tell you

FormLimit (2026)What that length is for
publicjobs Clerical Officer, assessment questionnaire Part AFour answers, 100 to 200 words eachOne event, three or four actions, one result. No room for background.
Council Grade IV to VII forms (Wicklow Executive Planner as an example)450 words per competencyFull STAR with a line on each indicator in the cluster and a reflection.
HSE forms on RezoomoText box per competency, no stated count; address the indicatorsAim at 250 to 350 words. Name the indicators you are evidencing.
publicjobs HEO and AP formsSet per competition; a selection of sub-dimensions is assessed at shortlistingThe booklet names which sub-dimensions. Write to those indicators, not the whole framework.

Two details from the AP 2026 circular apply more widely than AP. Candidates “are not expected to demonstrate or touch on all the behavioural indicators” in their forms, and “only a selection of capability dimensions/sub-dimensions are assessed at shortlisting stage”. So the job is depth on the indicators the form asks about, not coverage of everything.

The shape that scores

Written examples are marked like spoken ones, against indicators, so the STAR structure applies, with proportions shifted toward action. In 300 words: two sentences of situation with a date, a place and a scale; one sentence of task that names your responsibility; six to eight sentences of action in the first person, each one a thing you did that maps to an indicator; two sentences of result with a number or a named consequence; one sentence of what you learned or changed. The board is ticking indicators as it reads, so make the ticks easy: if the indicator says “setting realistic goals and timescales, taking account of potential problems”, write the sentence where you set the timescale and the sentence where you planned for the problem.

Three habits that lose shortlisting marks, in the order boards mention them. “We” where the board needs “I”: a team achievement with no visible part for you scores nothing for you. Generic claims in place of actions: “I have strong organisational skills and always meet deadlines” is a description of a competency, not evidence of it. And duty lists: “my role involves managing the roster, processing invoices and dealing with queries” is the job, not an example.

Example one: HSE Grade IV, Planning and Managing Resources

The 2026 Grade IV indicators under this heading: plans and organises own workload in an effective and methodical manner within strict deadlines; sets realistic goals and timescales, taking account of potential problems and competing priorities; devotes time and energy to the most important task at any given time; maintains an awareness of value for money.

Before

I am a highly organised person and in my current role as a Grade III in the outpatients department I am responsible for a wide range of administrative tasks including scheduling clinics, managing waiting lists, processing referrals and dealing with queries from patients and consultants. I always prioritise my workload to ensure deadlines are met and I am able to multitask effectively in a busy environment. For example, when we were short-staffed last year we all pulled together to make sure that the clinics ran smoothly and no patients were affected. I am also conscious of value for money and always try to use resources efficiently. I believe these skills would make me an effective Grade IV.

Why it would not shortlist: it is a duty list and a set of claims. The only event is told in “we” with no action of the writer’s. Not one indicator can be ticked from evidence.

After

In February 2026 our outpatients office in a Model 3 hospital lost two of five Grade III staff for six weeks at the same time, during the quarter when the department had committed to validating a 1,900-patient orthopaedic waiting list for the regional return by 31 March. I was asked by the Grade V to keep clinic scheduling running and to deliver the validation on time. I started by listing every recurring task with its real deadline and separating the ones with a patient or consultant waiting on them from the ones that could move. I set a daily target of 110 validation letters, which I calculated from the 1,900 total, the working days left and a 15 per cent allowance for returned post, and I agreed it with the Grade V so that it was a shared plan rather than my private one. I blocked the first ninety minutes of each day for validation before the phones got busy, moved the two weekly clinic template reviews to one fortnightly session, and asked the consultants’ secretaries to batch their referral queries to a single daily email, which cut interruptions substantially. When returned post ran at 22 per cent rather than 15 in week two, I raised the daily target to 125 and flagged to the Grade V that we might need one afternoon of agency cover in the final week; in the end we did not. We submitted the validated list on 27 March, four days early, with 1,742 patients confirmed and 158 removed or re-referred, and clinics ran with no cancelled slots over the six weeks. I used existing staff and post rather than the agency cover that had been offered, which I estimated saved around four agency days. What I learned was to build the contingency for returns into the plan from the first day rather than discovering it in week two, and I now do that for every return.

Why it shortlists: four indicators evidenced from named actions; a date, a scale and a deadline; “I” throughout with the Grade V’s role made clear; a result with figures; a reflection. At 340 words it fits a Rezoomo box, and at interview every sentence gives the board a probe you can answer.

Example two: council Grade V, Delivering Results

The LGMA cluster used by most councils for Staff Officer and above. Indicators: problem solving and decision making (pinpoints critical information, decides in time, considers the need for cross-organisational action); managing resources (allocates, uses and evaluates resources for efficient service delivery); delivering quality outcomes (organises delivery to meet or exceed the standard, identifies and shares learning). Wicklow allows 450 words per competency; this answer is about 380.

Before

In my current role as an Assistant Staff Officer in the Housing Department I am responsible for delivering results on a daily basis. I manage a busy caseload and ensure that all applications are processed within the target timeframes. I work closely with my colleagues and with other departments to resolve any issues that arise and I always look for ways to improve how we do things. Recently I was involved in a project to improve our processing times which was very successful and received positive feedback from management. I am results-focused and committed to delivering a quality service to the public.

Why it would not shortlist: “involved in a project” is the only event and it has no actions, no numbers and no named problem. The board cannot tick a single indicator.

After

In autumn 2025 the Housing Department I work in as an Assistant Staff Officer had a backlog of about 640 Housing Assistance Payment applications, with the oldest at eleven weeks against our published target of four. The Senior Executive Officer asked me to find out why and to bring the backlog under control before the end of the year. I pulled a sample of 60 files from the backlog and found that 41 of them were waiting on one of two things: landlord documentation we had requested by post, or a Revenue clearance check that was being done file by file. Neither was a staffing problem, so I did not ask for more staff. I drafted a single landlord checklist and a text-message reminder script, agreed the wording with the Senior Staff Officer and with our communications unit, and arranged for the two Clerical Officers on intake to send the text at day 5 and day 10 rather than a second letter. For the Revenue checks I spoke to the Finance Department, who already ran tax clearance checks on suppliers in weekly batches, and we agreed to put our landlord checks through the same weekly run rather than our one-at-a-time approach, which Finance preferred because it cut the ad hoc queries from us too. I set a weekly target of 70 files cleared and reported it to the SEO every Friday with the oldest-file age. By mid-December the backlog was 180 and the oldest file was five weeks; by the end of January it was within the four-week target. The landlord checklist was adopted by the two other housing teams in the county in February after I presented it at the section meeting. What I learned was to sample the backlog before proposing a fix, because the obvious answer, more staff, would not have touched the two causes that mattered.

Why it shortlists: the critical information was pinpointed by sampling, the decision not to request staff is explained, the cross-departmental action with Finance is there, resources were used differently rather than added, the outcome is measured against the published standard, and the learning was shared. Every indicator in the cluster has a sentence.

A checklist before you submit

The form is the first half of the interview. For the second half, the competency-based interview guide covers how the board questions the examples you wrote, and how Irish interview boards score shows the sheet your form and your answers both land on.

Questions people ask

How long should a competency example on an application form be?

As long as the form allows and no longer. The limits published in 2026 range widely: the Clerical Officer 2026 assessment questionnaire asked for four written answers of 100 to 200 words each; Wicklow County Council’s Executive Planner form allowed 450 words per competency; HSE forms on Rezoomo use text boxes per competency without a stated word count but with the instruction to address the indicators in the specification. Where there is no limit, 250 to 350 words is enough to show situation, your actions and a result; shortlisting boards read hundreds of forms and do not reward length.

Is the form actually scored?

Yes, when numbers require it. The HEO 2026 booklet says that where a competition attracts a large number of eligible candidates, "the shortlisting process will apply a scored assessment of the information provided on the application form" and a rank order is created. Limerick City and County Council scores shortlisting against each competency and warns that reaching 50 per cent in each does not guarantee an interview. The HSE job specifications say a ranking or shortlisting exercise may be carried out on the form against the eligibility criteria and the skills, competencies and knowledge section.

Can I use the same example for two competencies?

On the form, avoid it. The shortlisting board sees all your answers side by side, and the same story twice reads as thin experience. If one event genuinely covers two competencies, write two different parts of it: the planning for one heading, the difficult conversation inside it for another, with different actions in each.

Can I use ChatGPT or another AI tool to write the examples?

The HSE now asks you to disclose it and says that "where it is evident that a candidate relies entirely on AI answers for competency questions the application will not be progressed to the next stage" (Additional Campaign Information, 2026). publicjobs forbids AI assistance in the Clerical Officer assessment questionnaire outright. Beyond the rules, generated examples fail for a practical reason: they have no specifics, and specifics are what the board scores. The interview board then asks you about the form, and a story you did not write does not survive probing.

Will the interview board have read my form?

Yes, and it shapes the questions. The AP 2026 circular says the form "will be assessed during the shortlisting stage and will also inform the questions asked by the Interview Board". Council booklets say interviews follow the competencies highlighted in the application form, and candidates for every service report being asked to expand on their written examples. Contradicting your form at interview is on the list of red flags boards discuss afterwards.

Sources

StarMethod.ie is an independent practice tool and is not affiliated with publicjobs.ie, the Public Appointments Service, the HSE, An Garda Síochána, the Irish Prison Service or any local authority. Check dates and figures against the current booklet for your competition.

More guides